Wednesday, September 18, 2013

My book "Unnatural Act" was almost repped - A very nice NY agent said she smiled during the entire read - but it was "A man's book in a womens market."

I need to dial down the testosterone.

Here is a copy of her message to me....


Dear Reggie,

It's taken me an unconscionably long time to get back to you and I apologize.  The office move and its attendant chaos slowed me down, but we're up and running again. 

I've now read Unnatural Act and I'm torn.  You are outrageously funny, mordant, deliciously ironic.  I love the sensibility of this novel.  I certainly understand why Elizabeth George is taken with you.  I read the whole book with a smile.  Who can resist that?

However, after smiling till my face hurt, I confess I was less taken with the relentless, madcap, caperish romp through drugs, sex and rock n roll.  

The story doesn't unfold so much as hurtle.  It left me breathless, but I'm not sure that makes it convincing.  It's a guy's book in a girl's market.  I'm not sure how I would sell it. As much as I admire your talent, I'm afraid I'm not the right agent for you. 

I appreciate your thinking of me, and Elizabeth's recommendation.  I hope another agent disagrees with me and can knock it out of the park for you.  I'm glad I had the opportunity to read your work, and I wish you every success finding a home for it.

No comments:

Post a Comment